Resale value and replacement cost are different questions
- Topic
- Equipment valuations
- Reading time
- 3 minutes
- Last reviewed
On this page
A replacement quotation tells you what a particular replacement would cost. It does not tell you what a buyer will pay for your existing equipment. The replacement may be new, have different capabilities or include services that your sale does not offer.
Before comparing the figures, name the question each one answers. That makes the discussion more useful than arguing that a machine must be worth a certain amount because replacing it would be expensive.
Put the two offers beside each other
Consider this hypothetical situation. A business obtains a quotation for a new machine with delivery, installation and a specified support package. It also wants to sell an older machine that the buyer will collect, with only the documented accessories and condition information stated in the sale.
The figures concern different transactions. The quotation may still help identify specifications or an alternative available to a buyer, but it cannot be carried across as the used asset's price.
| Point to compare | Replacement quotation | Proposed resale |
|---|---|---|
| Equipment | Exact new or alternative model quoted | Actual make, model and configuration offered |
| Condition | Condition stated in the quotation | Observed and documented condition of the existing asset |
| Included services | Delivery, installation, support or other quoted work | Only the services and responsibilities agreed for this sale |
| Accessories | Quotation schedule | Actual included-item list |
| Timing | Supplier's stated availability | Seller's release and collection constraints |
| Purpose of figure | Budget for obtaining the replacement | Opinion or offer for disposing of the existing asset |
Leave a row unresolved where you lack the information. Do not assume that the replacement package and resale package include the same things.
A modern equivalent may be different
A current machine may provide similar useful output using different technology, capacity or operating arrangements. That can complicate a direct comparison. It can also explain why a functioning older asset faces a different buyer decision.
The guide to working equipment losing resale value explores those buyer requirements. Avoid concluding that newer is always better or that an old machine's usefulness has disappeared. The actual market and intended use need evidence.
Ask which figure the decision requires
For a proposed sale, use the equipment valuation process and ask what assumptions apply. For accounting, consult the appropriate adviser. The book-value comparison explains another figure that often enters the conversation but answers a separate question.
Insurance or financial reporting requirements may also specify their own purpose and basis. Do not submit a casual sale estimate where a recipient requires a particular professional report. Ask them what they need first.
Keep the assumptions visible
Attach the replacement quotation and its inclusions to the brief if it is relevant, but label it clearly. Read the valuation assumptions guide so that the resulting report does not silently change purpose as it passes between colleagues.
When asking UK Auction Group about equipment for disposal, provide the existing asset's details and the intended sale circumstances. The cost of buying something else can be context. The sale opinion still needs to concern the actual equipment you are offering.
Explore the valuations guides.
Professional reference: RICS.
Sources
This guide gives general information. Equipment-specific, legal, tax and safety decisions may need a qualified adviser or competent specialist. The guides do not promise sale prices, fees or results.